Blog, restaurant marketing, 9-minute read

A fish market got into The New York Times. Here is what we posted the month before.

On September 15, 2026 The Times named The Tides Market in Safety Harbor one of America’s best restaurants. The photograph they ran is ours. This is the content calendar from the 30 days before, post by post, with the numbers.

By Grant, co-founder of Orange Grove Social. November 2026.

Updated November 2026

Raw oysters on the half shell at The Tides Market in Safety Harbor, FL, photographed by Orange Grove Social
Oysters at The Tides Market, Safety Harbor. One of the frames from our September shoot.

The Tides Market did not get into The New York Times because of social media. It got in because Brett Anderson ate there and the fried fish sandwich and the blackened snapper were that good. What social media did was make sure that when the list went live, the account people found looked like the restaurant the Times described. Facebook added 5,226 followers in the 30 days before the list and 2,501 more in the week after it. Here is everything we posted in that month, what each post did, and the shoot plan behind it.

What happened on September 15

The New York Times published America’s Best Restaurants 2026, its list of the paper’s favorite places to eat in the country, and The Tides Seafood Market & Provisions in Safety Harbor was on it. It was the only Tampa Bay restaurant and one of two in Florida. The Tampa Bay Times, the St. Pete Catalyst and Creative Loafing all covered it within two days.

We have run The Tides’ social media since May 2026. Jon Walker, the owner and head chef, is on camera most weeks. The case study covers the first 60 days, when the account reached 2.5 million views on Meta with no ad spend. This post covers the 30 days before the Times list, August 15 to September 14, when the account was in its normal rhythm.

The month before, post by post

We published 20 feed posts in those 30 days, each on Instagram and Facebook, plus Stories. Ten were Jon on camera, shot on an iPhone. Six were photo carousels from our camera shoots. Four were quick announcements. Facebook did 843,758 views and 536,062 reach; Instagram did 189,376 views; the five Jon videos did another 150,200 on TikTok. The table is every feed post, newest last, with the view count on each platform as of the day we pulled it.

DatePostTypeFacebook viewsInstagram viewsTikTok views
Aug 13What is mignonette and how do you make itJon, iPhone15,01122,82724,200
Aug 14The Friday feast, dishes on the tablePhoto carousel6,4795,079—
Aug 15Weekend brunch hoursPhoto carousel3,6744,408—
Aug 17Market highlight: Queen & Colony honeyPhoto2,3482,576—
Aug 19The Queen Bee cocktailPhoto2,2012,424—
Aug 20Market b-roll, no wordsCinematic reel7,8953,530—
Aug 21Jon on the Seafood Monica pastaJon, iPhone14,4445,03914,800
Aug 21“Stumble on into The Tides” filmCinematic filmPosted to the feed and Stories; see it below
Aug 25“Kinda chic” trend, Tides editionPhoto carousel12,4427,359—
Aug 26Making our cocktail sauceJon, iPhone184,66210,71881,200
Aug 28Tampa Bay Times Best of the Best thank-youPhoto carousel11,3493,376—
Aug 30Words to live by, brunch hoursPhoto carousel4,8376,544—
Sep 1Jon on the shrimp risottoJon, iPhone19,4855,30714,100
Sep 3Beer and a blackened grouper sandwichCinematic reel9,7563,044—
Sep 4Closing two days for a fresh coat of paintPhoto8,891——
Sep 6Sunday brunch and an oyster shooterPhoto6,2084,700—
Sep 9Jon on why the grouper isn’t a perfect rectangleJon, iPhone12,3245,64515,900
Sep 10Welcome to the Oyster ClubPhoto carousel4,9729,913—
Sep 11The Pumpkin Cold Fashioned, sold outPhoto carousel19,5218,920—
Sep 13The holiday windows go upPhoto17,9625,091—
Sep 15Oysters and Crystal hot saucePhoto carousel4,7793,520—

TikTok is its own story. The account has 170,800 followers there, and Jon’s videos go up as the full two-to-four-minute take rather than the tight Reels cut. The five Jon videos from this month have done 150,200 TikTok views between them so far, led by the cocktail sauce at 81,200 and the mignonette at 24,200. TikTok counts keep climbing for months because a third of that account’s traffic comes from search, so these numbers are the view count on the day we pulled them, not a final score.

Three things stand out. Jon explaining one thing beat everything else: the cocktail sauce reel alone did 184,662 views on Facebook, 173 comments and 152 shares. Photo carousels did their job on Instagram, where the Oyster Club post got 81 shares and the Pumpkin Cold Fashioned got 115. And the announcements nobody plans for, a closure for paint and the holiday windows going up, pulled 8,891 and 17,962 views on Facebook because they were real.

Jon cooks the shrimp risotto on the line and talks through it. Shot on an iPhone with a lav mic, posted September 1.

The shoot plan: half iPhone, half cinematic

Every month at The Tides is split roughly in half. Half the effort goes to organic iPhone content: Jon at the counter with a lav mic, answering one question per video, cut long. Half goes to cinematic photo and video on a proper camera, the plated dishes, the oysters, the room, the owners. The first half is what gets watched. The second half is what makes the account look like a restaurant that takes its food seriously, and it is what editors and writers see when they look the place up.

The iPhone videos are not low effort. They are planned around questions people already ask: what is mignonette, why is the grouper that shape, how do you make the cocktail sauce. They run two to four minutes on TikTok and get a tighter cut for Reels. Jon does not read a script. He explains the thing the way he would to a customer at the counter.

You can watch the format on our reels page: Jon on oysters year round, the Tides burger, start to finish, why a fish market shouldn’t stink, the shrimp risotto, the pumpkin crème brûlée and the stone crab season update. Every one of them was shot on an iPhone in the kitchen or at the counter.

“Stumble on into The Tides,” the cinematic film we shot for the August 21 post.

The camera work is where the food gets its due. One shoot day a month produces the oyster, grouper and brunch photographs you see on this page and in our hospitality gallery, plus the cinematic reels like the market b-roll on August 20. Those frames fill the carousels, the website, the menu boards and, as it turned out, the newspaper.

Overhead of a seafood dinner spread on the table at The Tides Market, Safety Harbor
The cinematic half: one shoot day a month, shot on a full camera, lit for the plate.
The new artwork going up outside the market, shot on a full camera. The kind of piece that makes a feed look like a restaurant that takes itself seriously.

The week the list came out

Facebook views went from a 28,665 day on September 14 to 49,349 on the 15th and 66,303 on the 16th. The page added 500 followers on the 15th and 525 on the 16th, against a normal day of 100 to 300. Across the seven days after the list, Facebook did 325,445 views and 2,501 new follows, and Instagram did 72,127 views. Nothing about the content changed that week. The account was already posting Jon, the oysters and the fall cocktail, so the people arriving from the Times found a feed that matched the review.

That is the point of the month before. Press sends people to your profile for about 72 hours. What they find there is whatever you posted in the previous month.

The explainer format that carried the account all summer: one question, Jon answers it at the counter.

How our photograph ended up in the Times

The Times list runs a photograph with each restaurant. For The Tides they used one of ours, credited to Orange Grove Social. That is the direct result of the cinematic half of the shoot plan. When a restaurant has a library of properly shot, properly lit food and room photography, it is what the owner sends when a writer asks for an image, and it is what gets picked. Phone snapshots do not run in the Times. You can see more of the Tides photography in the case study, the hospitality gallery and on our portfolio site.

Jon and MK, owners of The Tides Market, photographed outside the restaurant in Safety Harbor, FL
Jon and MK outside the market. Owner portraits are part of every cinematic shoot day.

What another restaurant can copy

  1. Put the chef on camera once a week, on a phone. One question, one answer, no script. Ten of the 20 posts that month were this and they did most of the views.
  2. Shoot the food properly once a month. A camera, a lens and someone who lights a plate. That library is what fills carousels and what press uses.
  3. Post the real stuff. The closure for paint and the holiday windows outperformed most menu posts. Owners skip these; they should not.
  4. Keep the cadence through the quiet weeks. Press arrives without warning. The feed that is there when it does is the one you built in the month before.
  5. Have the photo ready. When a writer asks for an image, send a horizontal, high-resolution, properly lit frame the same day.

Questions restaurant owners ask

Did social media get The Tides into The New York Times?

No. The food and the restaurant did. Social media made sure the account people found after the list matched the review, and it is where the photograph the Times ran came from.

How much of the content was shot on an iPhone?

About half. Ten of the 20 feed posts in the month before the list were Jon on camera, shot on an iPhone with a lav mic. The other half came from a monthly camera shoot: photo carousels and cinematic reels.

How often did The Tides post?

Twenty feed posts in 30 days, so four or five a week, each on Instagram and Facebook, plus Stories most days.

What did the month cost?

The Tides is on our organic management plan, which includes one on-site shoot day a month, the calendar, posting and replies. Our clients pay between $2,700 and $4,000 a month depending on the shoot schedule and whether we run ads; see pricing.

Back to all posts